← Issue №18/ week of Nov 1, 2026/Esophagus/Reflux

Hiatal Hernia and Conclusive Gastroesophageal Reflux Disease: Size Matters.

From GI Signals issue №18: what this paper found, what it changes, and where it sits against the current standard of care, reviewed by Simon Mathews, MD.

Esophagus/Reflux retrospective · n=456 · Oct 30, 2026 · J Neurogastro Motil · IF 3.4

Hiatal Hernia and Conclusive Gastroesophageal Reflux Disease: Size Matters.

Practice-changingGERDproton pump inhibitorsesophageal motility
Clinical takeawayIn patients with suspected GERD and inconclusive initial findings, assess HH size as an additional anatomical marker to inform diagnostic confidence using Lyon Consensus 2.0 criteria.
What it foundPathological acid exposure time (AET) increased stepwise with hiatal hernia (HH) size: 19.3% in no HH, 41.2% in small HH (<3 cm), 51.3% in medium HH (3-5 cm), and 83.0% in large HH (>5 cm).
ContextSupports the Lyon Consensus by demonstrating a strong correlation between HH size and GERD severity, suggesting HH size may enhance diagnostic precision.
Refinessuggested applicable standard· British Society of Gastroenterology-endorsed international consensus, "Updates to the modern diagnosis of GERD: Lyon consensus 2.0" (Gyawali CP, Yadlapati R, Fass R, et al.), Gut, 2024

Decision at stakethe role of hiatal hernia size in assessing GERD using Lyon Consensus 2.0 criteria

No single passage of this standard matched the paper closely enough to quote, so none is shown. The standard is cited above.

Our full summary of this standard

For heartburn or regurgitation persisting despite PPI therapy, current practice (ACG 2022 GERD guideline, still the operative ACG guideline, plus the AGA 2022 personalized-GERD CPU) is to first optimize the PPI: confirm adherence, dose 30-60 minutes before meals, escalate to twice-daily dosing or switch agents for an 8-week trial. Empiric escalation to vonoprazan/P-CAB is NOT a routine pre-testing step: the AGA 2024 P-CAB clinical practice update advises against P-CABs as first-line therapy and reserves them for PPI failure with confirmatory GERD evidence (LA grade B or worse erosive esophagitis, biopsy-proven Barrett's, peptic stricture, or acid exposure time >6%). If symptoms persist after optimization, perform EGD (ideally 2-4 weeks off PPI when GERD is unproven) with esophageal biopsies to exclude EoE (>=15 eos/hpf; the ACG 2025 EoE guideline has removed the PPI trial from the diagnostic pathway) and then physiologic testing per Lyon Consensus 2.0: in unproven GERD, ambulatory reflux monitoring OFF therapy, applying Lyon 2.0's modality-specific thresholds -- on catheter-based single-day (24-hour) pH or pH-impedance, AET >6% is conclusive for GERD, 4-6% is inconclusive, and <4% argues against GERD; on prolonged wireless (Bravo, up to 96-hour) monitoring, AET >6% on >=2 days is conclusive for GERD while AET <4% on all days excludes it, and a study meeting neither threshold is inconclusive (the number of days with AET <4% carries prognostic weight for PPI discontinuation) -- and, in either modality, a normal-AET (<4%) study with positive symptom association indicates reflux hypersensitivity or, without it, functional heartburn; in previously proven GERD, pH-impedance ON optimized therapy, where AET >4% plus >80 reflux episodes defines actionable refractory GERD (MNBI <1500 ohms supportive, >2300 ohms against). High-resolution manometry per Chicago Classification 4.0 (still current) excludes achalasia and major motility disorders and is required before anti-reflux surgery. Therapy is phenotype-directed: surgical or endoscopic anti-reflux intervention for confirmed refractory pathologic reflux, and neuromodulators with or without brain-gut behavioral therapy for reflux hypersensitivity and functional heartburn.

British Society of Gastroenterology-endorsed international consensus, "Updates to the modern diagnosis of GERD: Lyon consensus 2.0" (Gyawali CP, Yadlapati R, Fass R, et al.), Gut, 2024 · reviewed 2026-07-23 ↗
Hernández JS … Gyawali CP · Journal of Neurogastroenterology and Motility · IF 3.4 · PubMed ↗Permalink
← Read the whole of issue №18 Every paper GI Signals surfaces gets a page like this one. All issues